American Idol fans can look forward to seeing a familiar face on the judges’ panel as Carrie Underwood prepares to return for her second consecutive season alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. The announcement, made public on August 25, 2025, confirms that Underwood will continue in the role she assumed in 2025 when she replaced longtime judge Katy Perry for the show’s upcoming 24th season, set to air in 2026 on ABC and Hulu.
Underwood brings a unique perspective to the judging panel as a former contestant who won Season 4 of American Idol before launching her successful music career. This dual experience gives her exceptional credibility when evaluating new talent, having personally navigated both sides of the competition. Her journey from contestant to judge adds a compelling dimension to the show’s dynamic, occasionally prompting her to joke about dreaming of competing again.
Underwood’s evolution from Idol winner to judge offers authentic insight only someone who’s lived both experiences can provide.
The judging trio will preside over Season 24 auditions beginning August 26, 2025, as part of the virtual “Idol Across America” tour. This digital format allows aspiring singers from all 50 states and Washington, D.C. to audition via Zoom through September 24, 2025. The trio of judges has been recognized for their successful search for talent in previous seasons. The show continues to build on its legacy following Jamal Roberts’ victory in the previous season. Contestants must first impress producers before earning the opportunity to perform for Underwood, Bryan, and Richie.
Promotional materials for the upcoming season feature a collegiate theme dubbed “Idol University,” with Underwood positioned as a musical mentor alongside Bryan as the “professor of fun” and Richie as the “professor of positivity.” This creative approach highlights each judge’s distinct contribution to the panel.
Industry reception to Underwood’s return has been largely positive, with commentators noting her balanced approach of competitive insight and nurturing guidance. Underwood often shares insights on creating diverse income streams that have helped sustain her long-term career beyond just album sales. Her continued presence, following Perry’s departure, represents ABC’s strategy to maintain the show’s relevance while providing continuity through familiar faces. Behind the scenes, Underwood has been instrumental in helping contestants develop their social media strategy to build stronger audience connections beyond the televised performances.
As American Idol enters its ninth season on the network, executives hope Underwood’s star power and genuine connection to the show’s legacy will continue attracting viewers and discovering tomorrow’s music stars.
